Alessandra Piccoli The Action Researcher Can Become a Crutch

Alessandra Piccoli writes …
“As action researchers, we often hope our work will empower people to take ownership of change in their communities. But what happens when the researcher becomes a little too important?
Have you ever experienced situations where a facilitator, leader, or researcher became indispensable to a project? How did your group respond?
For four years, I was involved in a participatory action research project accompanying the creation of a Community Supported Agriculture (CSA) initiative in northern Italy. A CSA is a food system in which consumers and farmers share responsibility, risks, and decisions around food production. It is also a powerful example of how communities can attempt to build more sustainable and democratic alternatives to conventional food systems.
The project began with enthusiasm.
Farmers and consumers came together to imagine a different way of producing and accessing food. Through interviews, discussions, collective reflection, and shared learning, the group developed new knowledge and a stronger understanding of agroecology, solidarity, and participation.
Yet, over time, I noticed something uncomfortable.
Many participants began to see me not only as a researcher, but also as the person responsible for keeping the project together. Expectations accumulated around my role. When problems emerged, people looked to me for solutions. Instead of strengthening collective autonomy, the research process was at risk of creating a form of dependency.
This experience forced me to ask a difficult question: can action research, despite its emancipatory ambitions, sometimes unintentionally undermine empowerment?
The answer I found lies in what I call shared reflexivity. Rather than treating reflexivity as something the researcher does alone, it became a collective practice. Together, we discussed expectations, responsibilities, frustrations, and power relationships. By making these dynamics visible, they could be questioned and renegotiated.
For me, this became one of the most important lessons of scholar activism: transformation is not only about changing the world around us. It is also about continuously examining how we relate to one another while trying to create that change.
Have you ever experienced situations where a facilitator, leader, or researcher became indispensable to a project? How did your group respond?
- Alessandra Piccoli The Action Researcher Can Become a Crutch - October 23, 2026
- Room for Spiritual Rituals by Catherine Dzerefos - October 16, 2026
- Eka Permanasari on Conflict Becomes the Point - September 14, 2026